Giants/Ravens trade (approved)

How is this deal not good? its madden not real life
simply put Rolle>webster
Mcgahee>Jacobs
Plax>#1 pick

its madden. you go by ratings. willis will be rated much higher than jacobs its easy as that

Ok i was offered a whole draft for Wayne and all he has to do is give up a FA pick this deal is lopsided and if this is more then 1 year Giants are getting owned because Rolle SUCKED this year and will be horrible next year as well and madden will drop him in ratings significantly

Seriously its just number man, it doesnt matter what the names are...simply numbers

plus burress only went up a little in tds and down in everything else his rating will drop a tad

and webster is yet to have a year close to Rolles best....

daBEARS wrote:

plus burress only went up a little in tds and down in everything else his rating will drop a tad

His ratings wont drop. He will be the same or higher. He wont get Points docked for have a few less yards but more TDs

Plax was only a 90 last year and dropped in everthing but TDs, its not like hes a 96 or anything

So whats going on with this..

You guys are beating this one waaayyy too hard...its not like either team is all of a sudden the supreme team of this league...they arent stacking a team or anything...

Ravens lose a great RB in McGahee, while the G-men lose a great WR in Burress...why dont we do this in a different light...

McGahee=Burress
Rolle>=Webster (for the sake of arguing)
#1 FA=Jacobs (still hasnt proved he can carry a full load)

I dont understand why this is such a problem for you guys...its not lopsided at all...its a pretty fair deal for both teams

i agreed with the trade but is it on or not?

yah, Mcgahee and Plax were both 90s last year and RB is a more important pos.

i agree wit cavs i think this is a pretty fair deal

cav_fan2 wrote:

You guys are beating this one waaayyy too hard...its not like either team is all of a sudden the supreme team of this league...they arent stacking a team or anything...

Ravens lose a great RB in McGahee, while the G-men lose a great WR in Burress...why dont we do this in a different light...

McGahee=Burress
Rolle>=Webster (for the sake of arguing)
#1 FA=Jacobs (still hasnt proved he can carry a full load)

I dont understand why this is such a problem for you guys...its not lopsided at all...its a pretty fair deal for both teams

perfecto

Most ppl seem to agree and the Giants Still Agree, it should be approved

Patstown wrote:

yah, Mcgahee and Plax were both 90s last year and RB is a more important pos.

no its not 70 RBs do jst as good as 80 RBs in madden WR is a much more important position since they can all hardly catch anyway

cav are you on trade council in bml?

cav_fan2 wrote:

You guys are beating this one waaayyy too hard...its not like either team is all of a sudden the supreme team of this league...they arent stacking a team or anything...

Ravens lose a great RB in McGahee, while the G-men lose a great WR in Burress...why dont we do this in a different light...

McGahee=Burress
Rolle>=Webster (for the sake of arguing)
#1 FA=Jacobs (still hasnt proved he can carry a full load)

I dont understand why this is such a problem for you guys...its not lopsided at all...its a pretty fair deal for both teams

Yah, perfect explination cavs, thanks

I dont want to ruffle any feathers, so I will wait for another Mod to agree first...

daBEARS wrote:

cav are you on trade council in bml?

Yeah, bears....I am

*edit* Wrong league bro...no Im not..wish I was...but I didnt make the cut I guess!

cav_fan2 wrote:

daBEARS wrote:

cav are you on trade council in bml?

Yeah, bears....I am

*edit* Wrong league bro...no Im not..wish I was...but I didnt make the cut I guess!

in bml? my league?

EDIT - welcome to the club my friend you explained this trade perfectly. you should of commented more on trades in BML. finally someone that doesnt look to deny trades right away

well ur very good at disecting trades and coming up with explinations

daBEARS wrote:

cav_fan2 wrote:

daBEARS wrote:

cav are you on trade council in bml?

Yeah, bears....I am

*edit* Wrong league bro...no Im not..wish I was...but I didnt make the cut I guess!

in bml? my league?

No Im not bro...Im not a Mod in that one...I edited my post...I thought you were talking about something else

Cav, you explained it perfect, the giants still agree and no1 is arguing anymore...can you approve it?

yeah dude well i put you on it now. you shouldve put more of your knowledge in trades. you explained this one pefectly. youre deff on it now.