Lions/Giants Trade(approved)

lebronzoom wrote:

silvabullet48 wrote:

lebronzoom wrote:

silvabullet48 wrote:

But this isn't real fantasy...this is madden.....people do not get inconsistent in madden

yes they do

please explain this to me plase...i have played madden for years and that has never happened...they always play the same

QBs get in throwing patterns, after youve missed like 5 passes it starts to get harder to complete them, on the flip side of this they can also start clicking. You may also notice that your team can get in losing skids.

pwned

you cant even say that. thats completly un-true. there are no patterns in a madden sim seasos im sorry to break your little heart.

i dont care either way but i just want to know

are you serious? Your simming the complete game, its not necessarilly just random numbers plastered all over the place. You think that Grossman will always put up numbers like a 93 QB because he did for half the season? Or the numbers of an 80 QB that he did for half the season

And isnt Consistency even a stat that the players get?

i hope so now, but it didnt used to be

I dont think it was actually called "consistency" but it measured the how consistant the player is

lebronzoom wrote:

I dont think it was actually called "consistency" but it measured the how consistant the player is

sorry but youre wrong. no such catagory

im probably thinking of 2k5 then.

But anyway, there is consistency factored into the game

no...no there really isnt

yes...yes there really is. Throw like 8 incompletions in a row then youll see that it gets slightly harder to make completions.

they better do this, it would make the game more realistic

Ok. Didnt see that before. Approved.

if this is a multi year league, kitna will not increase his overall much before he retires this is his 10th year plus hes 33 must people in madden retire at 34. he has absolutly no upside to him. manning was a former 1st pick is very young still his potential and upside, has room to improve his overall rating. make that second a late first and tis fine or add more

idc really, if tis what they want then do it, their ratings should be around the same, but Eli has much more upside and years left on him, so maybe it should be edited, dik

exactly its a multi year league, the second round pick will develop into a good player. The trade doesnt have to be exactly fair, and that pick might as well be a late first. Are you really going to argue over moving down 3 spots in the draft?

This is fair. The Giants want an experenced QB, or as so I think, so they chose Kitna. If the Giants agree, its approved.

lebronzoom wrote:

exactly its a multi year league, the second round pick will develop into a good player. The trade doesnt have to be exactly fair, and that pick might as well be a late first. Are you really going to argue over moving down 3 spots in the draft?

drew has denied about 100 trades because they were a little un fair.

here are some things


PLAYERS AGES
kitna-35
Manning-26
difference is 9 years


QB RATING
manning-77.6 and has slowing improving in time
Kitna-79.9
difference of 2.3

kitna has only a year or two left in the league before he retires and with the edition of drew stanton you can see there will be a race for the starter role in detriot while manning will be the number 1 Qb in new york for a long time and is slowly improving ...i just don't see a second round pick clarifling this....maybe if the pick could approve i wouldn''t mind

yea and I dont justify how drew judges trades, and not to mention that your doing the exact same thing drew is.

im giving him a taste of his own medicine

daBEARS wrote:

im giving him a taste of his own medicine

Screw off. Approved.

silvabullet48 wrote:

here are some things


PLAYERS AGES
kitna-35
Manning-26
difference is 9 years


QB RATING
manning-77.6 and has slowing improving in time
Kitna-79.9
difference of 2.3

kitna has only a year or two left in the league before he retires and with the edition of drew stanton you can see there will be a race for the starter role in detriot while manning will be the number 1 Qb in new york for a long time and is slowly improving ...i just don't see a second round pick clarifling this....maybe if the pick could approve i wouldn''t mind

are you serious? This is a madden league, Stanton players NO role in Kitna's overall. And Jon had that low of a passer rating only because of his INT's. You forgot to include how he threw for about 900 yards more than Manning did. Mannings great and all in the long run but if you want a good QB now then Kitnas the way to go. I believe that the Giants GM already clarified that hes not worrying about the future (and im sure that the reason for that is because hes already got the 34th pick invested in). That pick will get like an 80 overall player. And in time that player will probably become a low 90 (if hes played as a starter for the first couple years)